Is the barbell approach to asset allocation weakening SMSF portfolios?

  • 26.Mar.2018
  • Richard Murphy,  XTB

How to a construct diversified SMSF portfolio

Portfolio diversification is one of the key tenets that underpins Modern Portfolio Theory (MPT). Whether it’s an investment manager selecting bonds for a fixed income fund, a super fund investment committee determining the strategic asset allocations for members with different risk profiles, or a financial adviser devising an appropriate investment strategy for an SMSF, portfolio diversification is an important element.

The importance of diversification was encapsulated in MPT, developed by Harry Markowitz and first published in 1952. Markovitz hypothesised that investors could design an ‘optimal’ portfolio to maximise returns by taking on risk – and risk could be managed through diversification, both within asset classes and importantly, across asset classes.

The barbell

An analysis of SMSF portfolios indicates MPT has, to some degree, gone by the wayside. Recent asset allocation data indicates that many SMSFs adopt a ‘barbell’ approach, with a substantial exposure to equities at one end of the risk/return continuum, and a large weighting to cash at the other.

According to the ATO’s quarterly Self-managed super fund statistical report at end September 2017, the average SMSF had nearly half of its portfolio invested in equities and a quarter in cash and term deposits – of the remainder, an average of just one percent in bonds.


If you were to compare that with a professional investor, the asset allocation would look quite different – using the Colonial First State FirstChoice Balanced Option as a yardstick, while nearly half of the portfolio is invested in domestic and global equities, it has a 22 percent exposure to fixed income and less than 10 percent cash.

How to construct a diversified SMSF portfolio - professional investor portfolios contain a much higher percentage of bonds than SMSF portfolios

The equities domination

Whether accumulating retirement funds or drawing down, growth assets are important. However, even a very well diversified equity portfolio can fall prey to investor sentiment and suffer from a market downturn. In such an event, investors with 50 percent of their SMSF exposed to equity markets might experience sequencing risk.

Sequencing risk is the risk that the order and timing of investments is unfavourable. Volatility in markets and the order in which investment returns occur can make a substantial difference to the capital base once investors begin to draw on their retirement savings. If returns early in retirement are negative, then proportionately more capital is required to fund ongoing living expenses. This reduces the possibility of recouping losses over time.

Cash is not king

Although investors like the security of money in the bank, there’s a significant downside to this approach – longevity risk, or the risk of an investor outliving their savings. A recent study by National Seniors Australia found that while people are aware they’re likely to live longer, they are resigned to outliving their savings – just 50 percent had financially planned for a longer future. With rates now at their lowest since records began, cash investments barely keep pace with inflation; despite this, an average of 23 percent of SMSF portfolios lay idle in cash and term deposits.

The underrepresented bond

A diversified investment portfolio should include defensive assets, ones that balance exposure to growth assets such as equities and property. As a defensive asset, bonds can play an anchoring role in a diversified portfolio and in overlooking bonds in favour of cash and term deposits¹, investors miss out on the benefits that bonds can bring to an SMSF portfolio:

  1. An income stream

Bonds provide income from regular coupon payments, which are generally quarterly or half-yearly and occur on set dates. As a result, investors can accurately plan to match outgoings with the income they know will be received from bonds.

  1. Capital preservation

Bonds can provide capital stability. At maturity, a bond’s face value is returned to the investor, which makes a bond an effective capital preservation tool.

  1. Diversification of returns

As a defensive asset, bonds are not correlated with equities, and have a different risk and return profile. It’s this difference that provides the diversification benefit. While the prices of bonds will fluctuate according to interest rates and the economic cycle, historically bond prices have been considerably less volatile than share prices.

While investors can reap some of these benefits from a bond fund or ETF, a direct investment in bonds will enable an SMSF portfolio to really make the most of a bond’s unique features. Direct investment in bonds can be challenging, XTBs – exchange traded bond units, traded on ASX – can make them more accessible.

As well as providing capital stability and a predictable and regular income stream, the defensive nature of corporate bonds – and therefore XTBs – will generally result in low or negative correlation with equities.

These attributes make XTBs a worthwhile consideration for SMSF portfolios, to balance the risk/return profile and strengthen the portfolio by moving away from the barbell approach to asset allocation.

This article first appeared in selfmanagedsuper magazine

For a checklist of considerations for bond investors, click here

¹Term Deposits may enjoy the benefit of protection under the Financial Claims Scheme.

The information in this article is general in nature. It should not be the sole source of information. It does not take into account the investment objectives or circumstances of any particular investor. You should consider, with or without advice from a professional adviser, whether an investment is appropriate to your circumstances. Australian Corporate Bond Company Limited is the Securities Manager of XTBs and will earn fees in connection with an investment in XTBs.


  • 07Dec 2021

    YTMF13: ANZ BBSW + 1.00% 07 MAR 2022

    This is the coupon date

  • 07Dec 2021


    This is the coupon date

View Calendar
View Insights

Top insights stories

Take a hike Running Yield

Read Article

Bonds vs bond funds

Read Article

Australian banks made to sweat

Read Article

Is it time to float

Read Article